Matt Smith is incredible in HOD but the time jumps are jarring and it feels like they’re leaning into fan service a bit TOO hard. ROP feels less burdened by the source material and casting has been pretty stellar
I agree. The level of detail, production value, and just pure imagination is so incredible in Rings of Power. Also, even though I'm a big Tolkein fan, I'm really excited to see how the creators reimagine the material. Dragon is good -- but it's just Succession in Westeros.
HOD > Rings. I think you’re right about fan service, but also I don’t think that’s necessarily a bad thing. Rings is being a bit too slow, while HOT is like 15 pages in already from a 200+ page story, yet things feel like they’re actually moving